Status: Exhausted?

I created a wordlist with one word in it, the password I hashed.
then I put the hashed password in hashes.txt

the word was 'pikachu' (without quotation)

I ran:

cudahashcat64.exe -m 0 -a 0 -o cracked.txt hashes.txt Wordlists\wordlist1.txt

output:
cracked

My problem is, when I add more words to that wordlist of mine and change the password ('cus it's already been cracked), it just doesn't work.

I,E;

wordlist1:

Pikachu
Charizard
Pidgeotto
Charmander

Now, I hash 'Charizard'

then I run the same command;

cudahashcat64.exe -m 0 -a 0 -o cracked.txt hashes.txt Wordlists\wordlist1.txt

It tells me 'Exhausted'

What am I doing wrong?

It only works when my wordlist has the password, not when it has the password and other words in it.